Confidence interval for the variance of a normal distribution

The confidence interval for a population variance uses the chi-squared distribution, not the normal or \(t\), built around the sample variance \(S^2\) as the point estimate. Because the chi-squared distribution is right-skewed, the interval is asymmetric: the upper bound is always further from \(S^2\) than the lower bound. To compare the variability of two groups instead of one, see the CI for the ratio of two variances.

Formula

If the population is normal and we observe a sample of size \(n\) with sample variance \(S^2\), then:

\[\frac{(n-1)S^2}{\sigma^2} \sim \chi^2(n-1)\]

Inverting this pivot gives a \((1-\alpha)\) confidence interval for \(\sigma^2\):

\[\left(\frac{(n-1)S^2}{\chi^2_{1-\alpha/2,\; n-1}},\;\; \frac{(n-1)S^2}{\chi^2_{\alpha/2,\; n-1}}\right)\]

Note the order of the critical values: the larger chi-squared value (\(\chi^2_{1-\alpha/2}\)) goes in the denominator of the lower bound, and the smaller (\(\chi^2_{\alpha/2}\)) goes in the denominator of the upper bound.

For a confidence interval for the standard deviation \(\sigma\), take the square root of both endpoints.

⚠️ The CI for variance is not symmetric around S²

The CI for a mean is symmetric: \(\bar{x} - \text{ME}\) to \(\bar{x} + \text{ME}\). The CI for variance is not: the upper bound extends further above \(S^2\) than the lower bound extends below it.

This asymmetry comes directly from the right skew of the chi-squared distribution. For small \(n\), the asymmetry is substantial. For example, with \(n = 10\) and \(S^2 = 25\):

  • Lower bound: \((9 \times 25)/19.02 \approx 11.8\), which is \(13.2\) below \(S^2\).
  • Upper bound: \((9 \times 25)/2.70 \approx 83.3\), which is \(58.3\) above \(S^2\).

The upper bound is more than four times further from \(S^2\) than the lower bound.

Chi-squared distribution and critical values

Chi-squared distribution showing the critical values and rejection regions for a 95% confidence interval for variance

Step-by-step examples

Example 1: precision of a measurement instrument

A calibration lab tests a pressure gauge 20 times under identical conditions. The sample variance of the readings is \(S^2 = 4.2\) bar². Construct a 95% CI for the population variance.

Step 1: identify the ingredients.

\[n = 20, \quad S^2 = 4.2, \quad df = 19, \quad \alpha = 0.05\]

Step 2: find the critical values from the chi-squared table.

\[\chi^2_{0.975,\; 19} = 32.85, \qquad \chi^2_{0.025,\; 19} = 8.91\]

Step 3: compute the bounds.

\[\text{Lower} = \frac{19 \times 4.2}{32.85} = \frac{79.8}{32.85} \approx 2.43 \text{ bar}^2\]

\[\text{Upper} = \frac{19 \times 4.2}{8.91} = \frac{79.8}{8.91} \approx 8.96 \text{ bar}^2\]

\[\text{95\% CI for } \sigma^2: (2.43,\; 8.96) \text{ bar}^2\]

For the standard deviation: \((\sqrt{2.43},\; \sqrt{8.96}) = (1.56,\; 2.99)\) bar.

Example 2: packaging weight consistency

A food manufacturer samples 15 packages. The weights (in grams) give \(S^2 = 6.8\) g². Construct a 99% CI for \(\sigma^2\).

\[df = 14, \quad \chi^2_{0.995,\; 14} = 31.32, \quad \chi^2_{0.005,\; 14} = 4.07\]

\[\text{Lower} = \frac{14 \times 6.8}{31.32} \approx 3.04 \text{ g}^2, \qquad \text{Upper} = \frac{14 \times 6.8}{4.07} \approx 23.39 \text{ g}^2\]

\[\text{99\% CI for } \sigma^2: (3.04,\; 23.39) \text{ g}^2\]

The wide interval reflects both the small sample size (\(n=15\)) and the high confidence level (99%).

Bar chart showing the asymmetry of confidence intervals for variance compared to the symmetric CI for the mean

The upper bound (orange) is always further from \(S^2\) than the lower bound (blue), and the asymmetry is most pronounced for small samples.

⚠️ The normality assumption is critical here

Unlike the CI for a mean (which is robust to non-normality thanks to the CLT), the CI for variance derived from the chi-squared distribution is sensitive to departures from normality. For non-normal populations, this interval can be substantially incorrect even for large samples.

If normality is in doubt, consider:

  • Testing normality before applying the formula.
  • Using a bootstrap CI for variance, which does not assume normality.
  • Reporting \(S^2\) with a bootstrap confidence interval when the data is clearly skewed.

💡 Connection with hypothesis testing

A \((1-\alpha)\) CI for \(\sigma^2\) is directly connected to the chi-squared test for variance. If the hypothesized value \(\sigma^2_0\) falls outside the CI, the test \(H_0: \sigma^2 = \sigma^2_0\) is rejected at level \(\alpha\). If it falls inside, \(H_0\) is not rejected.

This duality means the CI carries all the information of the hypothesis test, and also shows by how much the hypothesized value is plausible or implausible.